Scoobie Davis Online

Sun Myung Moon Blog

Amway Blog

The YouTube Video "The World's Most Powerful Cult"

Talk Radio Transcripts
Rush Limbaugh1
Rush Limbaugh2
Sean Hannity1
Sean Hannity2
Matt Drudge
Andrew Napolitano
NewsMax1
NewsMax2
Tammy Bruce1
Tammy Bruce2
David Brock
Ann Coulter1
Ann Coulter2
Ann Coulter3
Clear Channel
Bill O'Reilly1
Bill O'Reilly2
Bill O'Reilly3
Bill O'Reilly4
Bill O'Reilly5
Bill O'Reilly6

What others are saying about Scoobie Davis:

"Naughty"
-Joe Conason

"Gadfly extraordinaire"
-Tom Tomorrow

Top Party Crasher
-Radar Magazine

"a nut"
-Bill O'Reilly

"media prankster"
-PRWeek

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
Web Sites That Rock
Salon
Am. Politics
Daily Howler
Buzzflash
Am. Prospect
Media Matters
Robert Parry
Slate
538
CAP
ConWebWatch
Air America
Greg Palast
Steal Back Your Vote
CREW
The New Yorker
Mother Jones
The Daily Beast
Trendhunter magazine
The Nation
Raw Story
HiLoBrow
HinesSite
VoteVets.org
TNR
Joe Conason
Ed Schultz
FAIR
Radar
Gawker
The Onion
DU
CLG
Eriposte
Move On
PFAW
Surfer Mag
Unprecedented
American Fundamentalists
Feed
PR Watch
High Times
Theocracy Watch
CSPI
Snopes
419 Eater
Buy Blue
Jack Chick
InTrade
Science of the Time
H+ Magazine
Tom Paine
Ken Wilber
Suicide Girls
Polling Report
Adbusters
Media T.
Alanis
Boing Boing
Rolling Stone
Never Get Busted
Zeta
Infiltration
Bill Berkowitz
John Robbins
Young Turks
Poynter
Global Politician
Fighting Words
Cursor
Online Journal
Anti-Rush1
Anti-Rush2

Blogs
Atrios
SlanderBlog
Amway Blog
Sun Myung Moon Blog
Googlebomb Blog
Josh Marshall
Daily Kos
Pandagon
Orcinus
Hullabaloo
Eric Alterman
Tom Tomorrow
Corrente
Calling All Wingnuts
Think Progress
MoxieGrrrl
America Blog
Wash Monthly
Ruy Teixeira
John Gorenfeld
Newshounds
David Corn
Mark Cripsin Miller
James Wolcott
Talk to Action
Crooks & Liars
Huffington
Firedoglake
ConsortiumBlog
My DD
Cliff Schecter
Brad Blog
Boorman Tribune
Kicking Ass
TalkLeft
Michael Moore
See The Forest
Roger Ailes
Salon Blog Report
Glen Greenwald
B-C
Taegan Goddard
Media Channel
Sideshow
Matthew Yglesias
Mark A.R. Kleiman
Tbogg
Oliver Willis
Skippy
Wonkette
Sadly No
Washington Interns
Political Realm
MF Blog
Move Left Media
Cranky Liberal
LeftField
Most Liberal
WTF
Politicky Bitch
Like Sunday
Autonomist
Funny Farm
Reflections on Playboy
utopia
Straight,Not Narrow
The Dude Minds
Rude Pundit
Margaret Cho
Dr. Limerick
Michael Berube
Elayne Riggs
Liberal Avenger
Crooked Timber
the stoRm
PD Dude
Demo Cali
The Agonist
SLA
Recovering Liberal
Breach
Smythe's World
NMMNB
Throwing Things
A La Gauche
Blah3
Timshel
Archpundit
Killer Empathy
Freeway Blogger
Dr. Forbush
Daily Blatt
Skimble
Pro. Gold
Dem Vet
David Sirota
Cut to the Chase
Est. Profit
Funny Farm
Brad DeLong
Mithras
BuffaloPundit
Bark,etc.
Amygdala
SK Bubba
Speedkill
LA Observed
Tapped

Film
IMDb
Filmmaker
Indie Slate
Moviemaker
Doc.org
IFC
Holy Cowboy
eXposure
Flicker
CinemaWeb
HOPE
filmmaking
Sundance
Film Threat
Unhollywood
AFI
FilmUnderground
Box Office
The Industry
indieWIRE

Reality Hacking/DIY/Crashing
Hacktivist
DIY Convention
CERI
BLF
Lycaeum
Erowoid
Infiltration
MAPS
The Partygoers
Kid Protocol
Robert Anton Wilson
GooglebombBlog
Jamming the Media
Boing Boing

Comix
Dan Clowes
Jack Chick
R Crumb
C B Galaxy
Fantagraphics
Will Eisner
Batton Lash
Tabloia
Comics Journal
Hard Drinkin' Lincoln
BiffSniff
Art Spiegelman
Joe Matt
Johnny Ryan
FreedomToons
Chris Ware
Charles Burns
Frazetta
Chris Ware
Neal Adams
Adrian Tomine
Scott McCloud
Last Gasp
ComicMix
PoopSheet
Harvey Pekar
Kevin Smith
Joe Sacco
D & Q

Reference
Webster's
Wikipedia
World Almanac
Internet Archive
What's It Worth?

Blogging Links
Blogger
Google Blog Search
Technorati
Findory
TailRank
Feedster
Blogdigger

Blogarama - The Blog Directory


Blog search directory
Blogwise - blog directory






Search Engine Optimization and Free Submission

[Powered by Blogger]
Weblog Commenting and Trackback by HaloScan.com
Reading List
Feed

Monday, March 10, 2003


Journalistic Misconduct by Two Fox News Analysts—And What You Can Do About It
For faithful readers of this site, I going to go over some territory that I have covered in the past, but with a new wrinkle. Those of you familiar with me know that I have railed against not only Sun Myung Moon but against his journalistic monstrosity, The Washington Times. Not only is the Times, in Paul Krugman’s words, a “house organ” for the Bush regime, but also it fosters an atmosphere of journalistic dishonesty.

One of the many instances of journalistic misconduct in the Times that has caught my attention was the one committed by reporter Bill Sammon. Sammon wrote the following in his best-selling book At Any Cost: How Al Gore Tried To Steal the Election (which was excerpted in the Times):

Gore was so upfront about putting his own skin above the national interest that, according to the Washington Post, he sat his senior aides down and drew them a picture. Literally. On an easel of butcher paper in the dining room of this residence at he Naval Observatory in Washington, Gore drew four concentric circles to represent his priorities. He and Lieberman occupied the innermost circle. The next circle was reserved for big supporters like CIO president John Sweeney, civil rights leader Jesse Jackson, and abortion advocate Kate Michelman. The Democratic Party was third in Gore’s circle of priorities. Finally, in the very last circle, Gore placed the country. The man who was seeking to lead the United States of America into the new millennium placed the national interest not first, not second, not even third. In Al Gore’s hierarchy of priorities, the nation came dead last.
Americans, alas, are a corny lot. They still like to think that their presidents place the national interest above their own. They would find it difficult to imagine men like George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, Franklin D. Roosevelt or Ronald Reagan drawing four concentric circles and explaining that their own hides were more important than the national interest. But Al Gore wasn’t like those other leaders. He was looking out for Number One, plain and simple.


Gore sounds like a real villain here. The only problem is that Sammon is lying. Here is the part of the Washington Post article that Sammon used to base his accusation that Gore “was looking out for Number One, plain and simple”:

The meeting was in the dining room. Gore’s wife, Tipper, snapped pictures and offered food. Gore occupied a central chair, beside two easels that held giant pads of paper...At one point, [Gore] drew a series of concentric circles to remind everyone of his circles of responsibility. At his innermost circle, he had responsibilities to himself and to Lieberman, then he moved outward through his closest supporters, Democrats as a whole and, in the largest circle, the country. He could not make critical decisions, he explained, without considering the larger context.

This excerpt illustrates why Sammon didn’t use footnotes in At Any Cost. The reason: if anyone were to check the Washington Post article that Sammon cited, it would reveal that the Post story reported the exact opposite of what Sammon was conveying to his readers. If it were not for the efforts of Bob Somerby of the Daily Howler, this libel would not have come to light. Somerby took the effort to find the original Washington Post article that Sammon cited; what he found was that Sammon had methodically misrepresented the article to give the opposite meaning of the article. Somerby did a painstakingly analysis of how Sammon did this. Somerby’s findings clearly indicate that the systematic omissions and paraphrases of the article by Sammon are such that a reasonable person is forced to conclude that Sammon consciously and systematically twisted the Post article to convey the opposite of its original meaning. I defy anyone to read the original Post article, Sammon’s representation of it, and Somerby’s response, and not conclude that Sammon engaged in gross journalistic misconduct and libel.

That Sammon is not jobless now is due to two things: 1) Sammon works for the Moonie-owned Washington Times and Fox News (as a Fox News Analyst)—two organizations that don’t care much about journalistic ethics; and 2) The lack of an effective echo chamber for the left. If progressives had a web site that receives the number of hits as the Drudge Report or if Drudge had analyzed Sammon’s words instead of promoting his books--then presently Bill Sammon would be considered a latter-day Janet Cooke instead of having two best-selling books (At Any Cost and Fighting Back). In fact, Cooke should be considered a rank amateur compared to Sammon. Cooke fabricated a story to benefit herself—nobody was hurt. Sammon stained the reputation of another person with his journalistic fraud.

Here’s where it gets interesting. While there isn’t much we can do to Sammon other than to report on his misconduct, we can address Washington Post reporter Ceci Connolly’s journalistic misconduct in this case. Connolly, like Sammon, is also a Fox News analyst. She also was one of the co-authors of the Post story that Sammon cited. I had written Connolly to see if she wanted to publicly comment on it; I received no response.

For being publicly silent on the matter, Connolly is in gross dereliction of her duties as a journalist. According to the Code of Ethics of the Society of Professional Journalists, it is the obligation of journalists to “[e]xpose unethical practices of journalists and the news media.” This is especially the case when another journalist who is engaging in libel grossly misrepresents one’s own reporting. In addition, the fact that both Connolly and Sammon serve as Fox News analysts raises serious questions about issues addressed by the aforementioned code—namely that: 1) Journalists should avoid conflicts of interest, real or perceived; 2) Journalists should remain free of associations and activities that may compromise integrity or damage credibility; and 3) Journalists should refuse gifts, favors, fees, free travel and special treatment, and shun secondary employment, political involvement, public office and service in community organizations if they compromise journalistic integrity.

While Connolly is clearly derelict regarding her not reporting Sammon’s journalistic misconduct, the other possible violations have not been established—this is clearly the job of an ombudsman. Connolly works for the Washington Post and it is an organization that at least tries to address journalistic misconduct (even though it employs someone like Connolly). Michael Getler, the ombudsman for Connolly’s primary employer, the Washington Post, should address these issues. Contact Michael Getler at ombudsman@washpost.com and inform him about Ceci Connolly’s misconduct. It’s important.


|

Home