Scoobie Davis Online

Sun Myung Moon Blog

Amway Blog

The YouTube Video "The World's Most Powerful Cult"

Talk Radio Transcripts
Rush Limbaugh1
Rush Limbaugh2
Sean Hannity1
Sean Hannity2
Matt Drudge
Andrew Napolitano
NewsMax1
NewsMax2
Tammy Bruce1
Tammy Bruce2
David Brock
Ann Coulter1
Ann Coulter2
Ann Coulter3
Clear Channel
Bill O'Reilly1
Bill O'Reilly2
Bill O'Reilly3
Bill O'Reilly4
Bill O'Reilly5
Bill O'Reilly6

What others are saying about Scoobie Davis:

"Naughty"
-Joe Conason

"Gadfly extraordinaire"
-Tom Tomorrow

Top Party Crasher
-Radar Magazine

"a nut"
-Bill O'Reilly

"media prankster"
-PRWeek

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
Web Sites That Rock
Salon
Am. Politics
Daily Howler
Buzzflash
Am. Prospect
Media Matters
Robert Parry
Slate
538
CAP
ConWebWatch
Air America
Greg Palast
Steal Back Your Vote
CREW
The New Yorker
Mother Jones
The Daily Beast
Trendhunter magazine
The Nation
Raw Story
HiLoBrow
HinesSite
VoteVets.org
TNR
Joe Conason
Ed Schultz
FAIR
Radar
Gawker
The Onion
DU
CLG
Eriposte
Move On
PFAW
Surfer Mag
Unprecedented
American Fundamentalists
Feed
PR Watch
High Times
Theocracy Watch
CSPI
Snopes
419 Eater
Buy Blue
Jack Chick
InTrade
Science of the Time
H+ Magazine
Tom Paine
Ken Wilber
Suicide Girls
Polling Report
Adbusters
Media T.
Alanis
Boing Boing
Rolling Stone
Never Get Busted
Zeta
Infiltration
Bill Berkowitz
John Robbins
Young Turks
Poynter
Global Politician
Fighting Words
Cursor
Online Journal
Anti-Rush1
Anti-Rush2

Blogs
Atrios
SlanderBlog
Amway Blog
Sun Myung Moon Blog
Googlebomb Blog
Josh Marshall
Daily Kos
Pandagon
Orcinus
Hullabaloo
Eric Alterman
Tom Tomorrow
Corrente
Calling All Wingnuts
Think Progress
MoxieGrrrl
America Blog
Wash Monthly
Ruy Teixeira
John Gorenfeld
Newshounds
David Corn
Mark Cripsin Miller
James Wolcott
Talk to Action
Crooks & Liars
Huffington
Firedoglake
ConsortiumBlog
My DD
Cliff Schecter
Brad Blog
Boorman Tribune
Kicking Ass
TalkLeft
Michael Moore
See The Forest
Roger Ailes
Salon Blog Report
Glen Greenwald
B-C
Taegan Goddard
Media Channel
Sideshow
Matthew Yglesias
Mark A.R. Kleiman
Tbogg
Oliver Willis
Skippy
Wonkette
Sadly No
Washington Interns
Political Realm
MF Blog
Move Left Media
Cranky Liberal
LeftField
Most Liberal
WTF
Politicky Bitch
Like Sunday
Autonomist
Funny Farm
Reflections on Playboy
utopia
Straight,Not Narrow
The Dude Minds
Rude Pundit
Margaret Cho
Dr. Limerick
Michael Berube
Elayne Riggs
Liberal Avenger
Crooked Timber
the stoRm
PD Dude
Demo Cali
The Agonist
SLA
Recovering Liberal
Breach
Smythe's World
NMMNB
Throwing Things
A La Gauche
Blah3
Timshel
Archpundit
Killer Empathy
Freeway Blogger
Dr. Forbush
Daily Blatt
Skimble
Pro. Gold
Dem Vet
David Sirota
Cut to the Chase
Est. Profit
Funny Farm
Brad DeLong
Mithras
BuffaloPundit
Bark,etc.
Amygdala
SK Bubba
Speedkill
LA Observed
Tapped

Film
IMDb
Filmmaker
Indie Slate
Moviemaker
Doc.org
IFC
Holy Cowboy
eXposure
Flicker
CinemaWeb
HOPE
filmmaking
Sundance
Film Threat
Unhollywood
AFI
FilmUnderground
Box Office
The Industry
indieWIRE

Reality Hacking/DIY/Crashing
Hacktivist
DIY Convention
CERI
BLF
Lycaeum
Erowoid
Infiltration
MAPS
The Partygoers
Kid Protocol
Robert Anton Wilson
GooglebombBlog
Jamming the Media
Boing Boing

Comix
Dan Clowes
Jack Chick
R Crumb
C B Galaxy
Fantagraphics
Will Eisner
Batton Lash
Tabloia
Comics Journal
Hard Drinkin' Lincoln
BiffSniff
Art Spiegelman
Joe Matt
Johnny Ryan
FreedomToons
Chris Ware
Charles Burns
Frazetta
Chris Ware
Neal Adams
Adrian Tomine
Scott McCloud
Last Gasp
ComicMix
PoopSheet
Harvey Pekar
Kevin Smith
Joe Sacco
D & Q

Reference
Webster's
Wikipedia
World Almanac
Internet Archive
What's It Worth?

Blogging Links
Blogger
Google Blog Search
Technorati
Findory
TailRank
Feedster
Blogdigger

Blogarama - The Blog Directory


Blog search directory
Blogwise - blog directory






Search Engine Optimization and Free Submission

[Powered by Blogger]
Weblog Commenting and Trackback by HaloScan.com
Reading List
Feed

Wednesday, July 09, 2003


Michael Savage: Free Speech Martyr?
Kudos to East Coast Bob. This phone prankster single-handedly got Michael Savage (Weiner) fired from his MSNBC show. In terms of the impact of televised phone pranks, East Coast Bob outdid Captain Janks, one of Howard Stern’s cronies, who in 1996 called the Rosie O’Donnell Show claiming to be Philadelphia major Ed Rendell and called O’Donnell “a big fat pig” on live TV (Don’t get me wrong; I thought Janks’ comments were cruel and uncalled for; I’m referring to the impact and publicity of the phone prank).

East Coast Bob got through when Savage was discussing airline horror stories and apparently began to insult Savage (he was partially muted) and Savage went off on him:

"So you're one of those sodomists. Are you a sodomite?" East Coast Bob replied: "Yes, I am." "Oh, you're one of the sodomites," Savage responded: "You should only get AIDS and die, you pig. How's that? Why don't you see if you can sue me, you pig. You got nothing better than to put me down, you piece of garbage. You have got nothing to do today, go eat a sausage and choke on it."

MSNBC was not amused. MSNBC canned Savage in a big hurry. "His comments were extremely inappropriate and the decision was an easy one," said an MSNBC spokesman. This leaves some unanswered questions. First, why was this lunkhead hired in the first place? As I wrote about Savage previously, this man is an addlebrained and barely coherent rabble-rouser (click here and go to “Isn’t It Ironic” to read the transcript of another of his outbursts).

Even many of the Freepers deplored Savage comments. But to Opinionjournal’s James Taranto, Savage is a free speech martyr who was “Dixie Chicked”—that is, Savage’s situation is comparable to the DC’s lead singer Natalie Maines who was pilloried after saying that she was ashamed to be from the same state as Not-My-President Bush.

Taranto is engaging in sophistry. This deserves elaboration. Savage’s situation differs from Maines’ situation in three major ways:
1) The nature of the words
2) The critics
3) How the critics responded to the words

First, the nature of the words. Taranto referred to Maines’ comment as “obnoxious.” Actually, it is rather mild compared to what Taranto’s cronies have said and written about President Clinton (more on this later). On the other hand, Savage’s words were hateful name-calling. Hoping that someone dies from AIDS is cruel. Also, Savage is sixty years old; suggesting that someone is a homosexual because one doesn’t like what another person says is a debating tactic that Savage should have abandoned sometime during Eisenhower’s first term. MSNBC was fully justified in getting rid of him.

The critics of Maines and Savage. Savage was rightly fired from MSNBC for his comments and MSNBC had a reasonable basis to make the decision. On the other hand, the biggest critics of Maines were people who were engaged in wholesale hypocrisy. Clear Channel, which was one of Maines’ most vocal critics, has in its employ, Rush Limbaugh, who has made vicious allegations against President Clinton and other Democrats. Limbaugh was part of the cabal (along with Roger Ailes) who planted the false story that the Clintons were responsible for the death of Vince Foster. More recently, Limbaugh questioned the courage and leadership of John Kerry, a decorated Vietnam commander (scroll down to May 22 and click here). By the way, Limbaugh used the pimple-on-the-ass excuse to get out of military service. Another of Maines’ prominent critics was Newsmax’s Christopher Ruddy, one of Scaife’s monkeyboys who was the godfather of the paranoid view that the Clintons were responsible for Foster’s death (Ruddy’s book on the matter was even criticized by fellow wingnut Ann Coulter as “conservative hoax book”).

Let’s look at the response of the critics to the words of Savage and Maines. With Savage, MSNBC fired him and gave a reasonable explanation for the firing. Commentators on the matter have generally acknowledged that Savage is a whacko and that his sodomite comments were consistent with his previous rhetoric—a fair criticism. On the other hand, after Maines made the comment, the critics acted as if she made an attack on America and the office of the presidency (mind you, these were the same people who lied with impunity about President Clinton). Maines was denounced as “anti-American” and “pro-Saddam” without a shred of evidence for these conclusions. Ruddy and Newsmax created a Deck of Weasels playing card deck that included Maines and others pictured with Saddam hats superimposed on their heads. The American right was whipped up into a frenzy and Maines received numerous death threats from right-wing rabble.

Maines gave her opinion of George W. Bush. It was a reasonable, especially if we compare it to criticisms of Bill Clinton made by the usual suspects: Coulter, Limbaugh, Ailes, Ruddy, Farah, and Horowitz. For this, she was demonized by these same people who thought nothing of engaging in a wholesale smear campaign against the Clintons. Savage made some idiotic comments and got his just desserts.

Addendum: I thank the folks at American Politics Journal for directing me to the audio clip of Savage’s show to me.


|

Home